The person I am caring for may be involved in a police matter or legal trouble.

The person I am caring for may be involved in a police matter or legal trouble.

Being called up by the police for an interview is not the same as being arrested. However, it can be stressful and confusing, particularly for someone with an intellectual disability, autism or mental health issue. Here is what you can do:

  1. Contact the police station to understand the reason for the interview and what it involves.
  2. Consider applying for an Appropriate Adult: The Appropriate Adult Scheme for Persons with Mental Disabilities (AAPMD) run by MINDS provides trained volunteers who can accompany a person with an intellectual disability, autism spectrum disorder, or mental health issue during police interviews. The Appropriate Adult is there to support and facilitate communication—they are not a lawyer, but they help ensure the person understands what is happening and can communicate effectively.
  3. Engage a lawyer: You may wish to consult a lawyer before the interview takes place, even if the person is not under arrest. 
  4. Stay calm and supportive: Help the person understand what will happen and accompany them if permitted.

Being arrested means the police believe there are reasonable grounds to suspect the person has committed an offence. Here is what to expect:

  1. Arrest and investigation: The person may be questioned by police. Consider applying for an Appropriate Adult. The Appropriate Adult Scheme for Persons with Mental Disabilities (AAPMD) run by MINDS provides trained volunteers who can accompany a person with an intellectual disability, autism spectrum disorder, or mental health issue during police interviews. The Appropriate Adult is there to support and facilitate communication—they are not a lawyer, but they help ensure the person understands what is happening and can communicate effectively.
  2. Engage a lawyer: It is important to engage a lawyer as soon as possible. Legal aid may be available if they cannot afford one.
  3. Mental health assessment: The person may be referred for a psychiatric or psychological assessment. 
  4. Court proceedings: If charged, the person will appear in court. The courts have recognised that a person's intellectual disability may mean they are unsuitable as a medium for general deterrence, and their inability to fully appreciate the significance of their acts may reduce the weight given to deterrence in sentencing. The court will consider their mental condition when determining how to proceed. Options may include: 
    • Discharge without prosecution (if the person is not fit to plead or the public interest does not require prosecution).
    • A Mandatory Treatment Order if a psychiatrist certifies they have a mental disorder that contributed to the offending.
    • Probation or community-based sentencing.
  5. Community Forensic Services by MINDS: MINDS provides case management support for persons with intellectual disabilities who are going through the criminal justice process, from arrest through to post-sentencing.

An MTO is a type of community-based sentencing. Instead of sending an offender to prison, the court may order them to undergo psychiatric treatment in the community (such as attending regular psychiatric sessions at a hospital). Before an MTO can be made, an appointed psychiatrist must provide a report confirming that: (a) the offender is suffering from a treatable psychiatric condition; (b) the condition contributed to the commission of the offence; and (c) the offender is suitable for treatment. All three requirements must be satisfied before the court can make an MTO.

It can—but it depends on the nature and severity of the condition and its connection to the offence. The severity of an offender’s sentence is determined primarily by the harm caused by the offence and the offender’s culpability (how responsible he or she can be held for his or her offending). Mental conditions do not automatically reduce culpability, there must be some contributory or causal link of the condition with the offending conduct.

The Mental Health (Care and Treatment) Act 2008 (MHCTA) allows for the apprehension of a person who is reported to be mentally disordered and is believed to be dangerous to themselves or to others, for the purposes of referral for treatment.

 

If someone calls the police or another authority and says they are concerned that a person appears to have a mental disorder and may be dangerous, the police may apprehend that person and take them to see a doctor. Once apprehended, the person must be taken without delay to a medical practitioner for examination.

 

It does not follow that someone will automatically be admitted to a psychiatric hospital simply because they are apprehended under the MHCTA. The medical examination is the next step, and further decisions depend on the outcome of that examination.

"Dangerous" behaviour may include arming oneself with a knife, threatening others, or putting oneself in a precarious physical position.

 

In practice, whether someone is "dangerous" will depend on the circumstances as assessed by the police at the time. The concern is whether there is a belief, on reasonable grounds, that the person poses a risk to themselves or others.

Find out more:

 

Legal Guidance and Representation:

  • Legal Aid: Check what legal aid you can apply for here (Note: legal aid is for individuals unable to afford a lawyer, and the application process will likely involve means-testing).
  • Find a Lawyer: If you do not qualify for legal aid, you may find a lawyer using the following directories:

 

Social assistance: 

  • Community Forensic Services. MINDS: Adopts a community-based case management approach in supporting offenders, victims and/or witnesses with intellectual disability through the stages of arrest, investigation, prosecution, trial, sentencing and post-sentencing. 
  • Appropriate Adult Scheme for Persons with Mental Disabilities (AAPMD). MINDS: Provides assistance to persons with intellectual disabilities, autism spectrum disorders or mental health issues, who have to undergo interviews with Investigation Officers at law enforcement agencies through trained volunteers.
  • Appropriate Adult Scheme for Young Suspects. Children’s Society: The scheme aims to ensure the well-being of children and young persons during law enforcement interviews in the presence of a neutral adult.
  • Appropriate Adult Scheme for Young Suspects. Care Corner: Provides support to young people under the age of 18 during police or law enforcement interviews. This scheme ensures that a trained, independent and dedicated Appropriate Adult volunteer will accompany young suspects during interviews to ensure the young person’s well-being.